In the rush to assign blame for the Pahalgam attack, India’s narrative cast an unusually wide net, implicating groups and states ranging from Hamas to Huawei, yet offered no coherent, evidence-based framework connecting these actors.
A comprehensive Stratheia dossier is enclosed, which critically examines the Indian state’s narrative construction. What we got instead of evidence was a spectacle, a matrix of overlapping blame that looped in Hamas, China, Turkey and even digital infrastructure firms like Huawei. The accused circle widened, but its coherence thinned. Satellite imagery, social media chatter and statements were mobilized with such rapidity that they pointed less to forensic investigation and more to narrative premeditation.
Pakistan’s response, unusually assertive and forensic, was a shift in posture. In addition to rejecting the allegations, Islamabad pointed out procedural inconsistencies, challenged fabricated timelines and opened its territories to foreign observers. Denial was not the aim; it was a structured rebuttal, with the gaps in India’s epistemic claims laid bare and the increasing use of tragedy as a strategic tool.
Breaking with its traditional defensive tone, Pakistan mounted a proactive, fact-based rebuttal, challenging India’s timeline, exposing inconsistencies, and inviting international scrutiny, an unprecedented diplomatic move signaling confidence in its position.
The dossier concludes with a chilling insight that the Pahalgam episode is not a case of misattribution, but a symptom of a collapsing evidentiary standard in international relations. Global diplomacy is in dangerous terrain when accusation becomes strategy and truth becomes optional. So Pahalgam is a cautionary tale, not just about Pakistan or India, but about how quickly fear can be weaponized and how easily the architecture of truth can be destroyed in the age of narrative warfare.
India’s response to the attack prioritized performance over proof, deploying satellite images, social media clips, and selective political statements in a media blitz that resembled a theatrical rollout more than a forensic investigation.
Research at Stratheia is driven by the need to find clarity in confusion, facts in fury. This dossier is a part of that commitment to hold narratives accountable, not to score points, but to preserve the integrity of global norms and investigative standards. The dossier reminds us that in the end, what is remembered must first be proven.
View report
Click Here to Download!
